Buyer Beware

Yesterday the Rangers signed Japanese pitcher, Yu Darvish, to a six year, 60 million dollar deal. Last year in Japan his record was 18-6 with a 1.44 ERA and 276 strikeouts to go along with it. Also, in 2009 during the World Baseball Classic he posted a 2-1 record with a 2.33 ERA helping Japan take home the title. Incredibly he has posted 5 consecutive seasons of an ERA under 2.00 and a WHIP under 1.00 except in 2010 when it was 1.01 in Japan. Sounds dominant right? Well lets take a look at another stat. Yu Darvish is 25 years old, he has been pitching professionally for 7 years now, and for 5 consecutive seasons he has pitched at least 180 innings. To some people this says durability and it could mean that. To me, its a red flag. How many 25 year old pitchers do you know that have logged 1268 professional innings? I’m not from the school of limiting innings and pitch counts because when I was in high school and college I took great care of my arm with regimented routine and never experienced any arm issues. What worries me is, the Rangers invested 60 million and posted a 51.7 million dollar bidding fee so naturally they will want to condition him to their standards. Anytime you take someone out of a routine they have done for an extended period of time it will stress the body which can lead to an injury. Just look at Daisuke Matsuzaka. Daisuke had limited success in his first year then posted a career year the second time around. Following that 2008 season Daisuke has struggled with injuries and wasn’t healthy until this past season. When Daisuke came over he had thrown 1163 career innings in Japan. Sound familiar to someone? Also, many people forget that a big issue between the Red Sox training staff and Daisuke was his training regiment. Could the same thing happen between the Rangers and Darvish? I realize that Daisuke didn’t project as well as Darvish does but the comparison is still warranted. Darvish has three above average pitches, good command, and we have already seen him against top competition during the World Baseball Classic. I have two questions about Darvish: Can he sustain this success against the best hitters in the world and will the heavy work load on his arm affect his effectiveness two or three seasons down the road? What defines greatness is not one or two great season but continued success as the hitters gain more and more information on your pitching tendencies. Will we see his fastball mph dip a couple points and force him to pitch more creatively? Will the wear and tear eventually force an injury? Okay, so maybe I have more than two questions but the Rangers are shelling out money for greatness. I understand why they did it. They felt backed into a corner when C.J Wilson jumped cloud to the Angels so I understand the risk they are taking. The only advice I can offer, buyer beware.




27










